Posts Tagged ‘Thomson Reuters’
U.S. Magistrate Judge Roanne Mann’s redistricting proposal would eliminate one district in Queens and Brooklyn, which is represented by Republican Congressman Bob Turner, and another in New York’s Hudson Valley, represented by Rep. Maurice Hinchey. Hinchey, a Democrat, is retiring this year.
New York must redo its congressional maps to reflect population shifts identified in the 2010 census. The state is losing two of its 29 seats in the U.S. House of Representatives.
The Democrat-dominated Assembly, the Republican-controlled Senate, and Assembly Minority Leader Brian Kolb on Wednesday handed in the maps to U.S. Magistrate Judge Roanne Mann, who is acting as a special master in a lawsuit challenging a legislative “impasse” over the redistricting process.
The Assembly, Senate and Kolb are defendants in the suit, Favors v. Cuomo, which was filed by a group of voters and community leaders in November.
The conference was scheduled last week after a judge denied a bid to dismiss a lawsuit brought by voters and community leaders, who had asked the court to intervene in the redistricting process.
“It’s going to be a circus,” said Juan Cartagena, an attorney at LatinoJustice PRLDEF, who represents a group of Latino voters involved the case.
New York, like other states, must redo its political maps in light of population shifts identified in the 2010 census.
The group, led by Senator Betty Little, a Republican from Warren County, filed a lawsuit last year claiming the 2010 law was unconstitutional. The state senators, whose upstate districts include prisons, wanted to reinstate the old method of counting prisoners where they are incarcerated, a practice opponents call “prison gerrymandering.”
The law, passed in 2010, requires all prisoners to be counted as residents of their home communities, not the town of their incarceration — a practice known as “prison gerrymandering.”
A group of Republican state senators brought a lawsuit challenging the law, arguing that it violated New York’s constitution. But in December, Supreme Court Justice Eugene Devine of Albany County rejected that claim and found the law was constitutional.
In a decision issued Monday, U.S. District Judge Dora Irizarry in Brooklyn gave the panel authority to appoint a special master to draw up new congressional districts if a legislative stalemate over the drawing of the state’s political map continues.
The lawsuit, filed Thursday in Brooklyn federal court, also alleges that the population data used by the New York State Legislative Task Force on Demographic Research and Reapportionment, or LATFOR — which oversees the redrawing of New York’s congressional districts every decade — is improperly counting prisoners outside of their home residences.
Lawyers for the group argued before state Supreme Court Justice Eugene Devine that the law, which requires state prison inmates to be counted as residents of their hometowns for the purpose of redrawing legislative districts, is unconstitutional because it creates two separate census counts.
Earlier this month, Supreme Court Justice Eugene Devine allowed the voters to intervene as defendants in an action brought by upstate senators and some of their constituents. The suit sought to block a 2010 law that counts prisoners as residents of the community where they last lived, rather than where they are incarcerated.
The 15 people are supporters of a 2010 law that counts prisoners as residents of the communities where they lived before incarceration instead of the communities where they are detained.

